Avatar Gaze Breaks Fourth Wall

I’ve done a lot of pontificating about avatar gaze in virtual worlds (eye contact, and all the emotional and sometimes strange effects that this causes). I’m writing a paper called Virtual Gaze, soon to be published in a book by  ETC PressWhile checking on other references to avatar gaze, I came across this blog post by Ironyca about the avatars in Blue Mars. Here’s a picture from that blog:

That avatar is looking at ME! Creepy.

Wagner James Au comments on this effect in a blog post. He quotes the engineer who added this feature (Koji Nagashima):

“On a cinematic project,” Koji explains, “all animators carefully make animation for eyes. But in our world, the program needs to take care of that.” Eye animation in a virtual world or MMO is challenging because the avatar’s position or the user’s camera changes so often. “That’s very interesting for me,” Koji says.

Okay guys. It’s interesting, I agree. And it’s a cute trick. But it makes no sense to me. Have you thought about the media effects? Do you understand how this creeps out users? In cinema, there is this concept of Breaking the Fourth Wall, which refers to a fictional character acknowledging the reader/viewer/audience, and acknowledging the fact that he or she is fictional. The fourth wall, in this case, is the computer screen. So, what is the reason you broke this wall?

I developed avatar gaze code for There.com. This is described in my chapter, The Three Dimensional Music of Gaze. Gaze is a powerful form of body language, and virtual worlds, by and large, are still lacking in this form of expressive connectivity. The silent act of shooting a bit of eye contact on someone’s avatar can be a signal to start a conversation. It can show attraction, and it can show WHO YOU ARE TALKING TO (one bit of affordance that is often missing in virtual worlds). It can also create romantic effects, as shown in these pictures from There.com (the left image shows a prototype I developed with Chuck Clanton for chat props).

The Look

In real life, my wife only needs to make one quick glance at me, and I know that it is time to take out the trash. Or…depending on the timing, or the situation…it may mean something else entirely: something which is more fun than taking out the trash. This simple bit of body language is powerful indeed. Virtual gaze can enliven virtual worlds – infusing silent communicative energy between avatar faces. Virtual gaze gives virtual worlds increased validation as a communication medium of embodiment.


As far as Koji’s trick of having avatars break the fourth wall, I’d like to hear what you think. How does this effect the Blue Mars experience? Ironyca’s critique says it better than I could:

“At least she kept looking at me! I have always thought of an avatar as a virtual representation of me in cyberspace, but perhaps Blue Mars disagrees. To me, the identity immersion was completely broken by the fact my avatar liked to look at me (i.e. gaze at the “camera”), and sometimes her posing even looked flirtatious. I was highly disturbed by the fact, that my idea of her and me being the same was thrown overboard, when she continously decided to turn her head and smile at me. If she is looking at ME, I can’t be HER.”

3 Responses to Avatar Gaze Breaks Fourth Wall

  1. ironyca says:

    Hehe I wasn’t even exaggerating when I wrote that article, they really did freak me out. I spent a long time experimenting with it because it was so odd. It was especially bad with several avatars as sometimes the camera would trigger them all to turn their heads and look at you.
    It does make the avatars seem more autonomous, but is that what we want?

  2. Soede says:

    The Look caught me off guard the first few times, and I do think it’s a bit too frequent but I like the effect. Better though is when the avatars of other people look at you.

  3. PBS’s “Nova Science Now” has an episode entitled “What’s the Next Big Thing?”. In one of the articles they describe how robotics developers are tackling the issue of teaching and engineering robots how to mimic human behavior so as to help us “like” them better and feel good about interacting with them. It would seem logical that this type of engineering would apply to avatar design as well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: